We have a Chloe. When I first got pregnant, I was anti-popular name. But my DH and I do not have the same taste in names at all, so finding a name, any name, that we both semi-like is a miracle. I suggested Claudia to DH, which of course he shot down, and Chloe popped in my head so I mentioned it, and he didn't hate it, so we put it on the list.
Before she was born, and even a bit after, I struggled a bit internally with the popularity of Chloe. But every time we discussed names, we'd end up arguing, and eventually I thought, using a popular name that we both like is a heck of a lot better than fighting over names that he or I will never come around to.
We have run into two other Chloes since she's been born, but we run into more Londons, which was #119 the year my oldest DD was born. Chloe totally suits my DD now; it's short and spunky, just like she is.
FWIW, I think Sofia/Sophia is a beatiful name. I'm curious what you other top name is!