Zoey is my favorite - one that I'm thinking about as well!
Natalia is very pretty, and so is Lilyanah (although that spelling is too much for me, I prefer Liliana). And I'd pronounce it Lily-ah-na.
I'm not a fan of Naomi, and I like Izabella (but not with a z, much less harsh-looking with an s), but I think it's become way too popular...