MrsI:I think it really depends on what kind of "shower" you plan on having. The first says lets celebrate with a baby shower. While the second says you are cordially invited to a baby shower which to me says its a fancier party. That might just be my understanding of it though....
I can change the wording so that's not an issue. Both have the same look for me. Just the matter of which look is better. It's crazy how the mom-to-be looks like her too on the first one. I do like the darker dress and ornament feel. Think I might go toward the second one. I love how she's holding the booties in one hand.