Meh. I had a top 5 name growing up, and even, at one point, had a girl in my class in elementary school who had the same first and last name as me (also a very common last name!). Honestly, I did not mind having a popular name. I would much rather have had a popular name than been the strange kid out with a weird name. My sibling had a made up name, and he still does not use it to this day. I feel like my popular name made things easier for me.
So, when I look at my kids names I am not aiming to find the most unusual name I can. I guess I did cross Sophia and Jacob off my list b/c they are SO popular, but I still have no regrets about using Noah, which is now #5 (it was #19 on the latest SSA chart I had available when I named him). I love his name. It is classic, it has always been one of my favorite names, and I think I would have had regret if I had NOT used it. I think Amelia is in a similar category (classic).