I like several names in the top 50 even but I prefer to use one generally past 150 for girls. DH loves Elizabeth (11 last year but frequently in top 10) but if he didn't like it so much and disliked so much of what I liked then I would cross it off just for that. And it's weird that he hasn't because he has crossed off Charlotte and Grace for being too popular.
For boys, our list includes a spot at 231, 3, and 8 for first names. Without DH though, I like pretty obscure Bible names that usually don't even rank at all.