We have a regional consignment sale that happens twice a year in our community that seems to draw a lot of sellers and buyers. Ours is a franchise that is called Kids Closet Connection, but there are a lot of similar events.
We have that same sale here twice a year. I just went to the Fall one and got some great toys for DS super cheap. It was great! I would definitely consider selling stuff there next Spring. In the meantime, I have a couple barely used really nice items that I'd love to unload now, but if I can't, they will definitely be going to a future consignment sale.