First of all, GREAT list. We started out with many of the same names.
Ava - love, but was too popular for me
Claire - love (my MN)
Avery - like, but my husband vetoed as being "too masculine"
Elise - okay
Ellie - eh. Seems like more of a nn to me.
Ella - love
Sophia - WAY too popular, and I really dislike the nn Sophie
Brielle - no
Aria - no
Sadie - no
Mila - no
Gemma - no
Gracelyn - no
Emmeline - LOVE
Hadley - can't get behind this after reading "The Paris Wife" - couldn't name my daughter after such a weak female character
Grace - LOVE (our current first choice)
Kate - ove, but only as a nn for Katherine
Brynn - love
Blair - no, too 80s
Alessandra - no, seems made up
Anneliese - no
Isabella - way too popular, way too much "Twilight" association
Gabriella- no, too 80s
Maeve - bad personal association
Camilla - no, but I like Camille
Greta - like, but what about Gretchen? (like that more)