My favorites on your list (not in any order):
Abigail Page Claire
Olivia Kate Claire (yes, Olivia is super popular right now, but I love this combination and it just struck me for some reason)
Savannah Paige Claire
Emily Marie Claire
I think Sienna is an ok name, but not with Brooke, as Sienna is a color and it sounds like it is describing the brook (as in, the stream). So that name basically means "brown stream" - eeeeew.
I really don't like any of the rest of the options. You have some great names above to chose from, I think the rest can be easily discarded.