I would look at the Graco My Ride. It has a built in cup holder, and it should get most kids to 3-4 rear-facing and around 5 forward facing.
You could also look at the Graco My Size 70/Size 4 Me 70/Headwise 70. However, I would highly suggest keeping your receipt, because many people including myself have had harness issues with the seat. Sometimes the harness won't tighten enough. I have one now that doesn't have harness issues, but I had several before getting one without issues.
I wouldn't suggest any of the Eddie Bauer or Alpha Omega seats. They are a jack of all trades, master of none.